Xinysun Instrument (Shanghai) Co., Ltd.

Applications

Breadcrumb: Home > Applications > Lab Research

Phototoxicity Assessment of Triazine Sunscreens: Application of LUYOR-3450 in the 3T3 NRU Test

Updated:2026-11-02Views:

This article takes apart the design of a safety study on two triazine UV filters: how the 3T3 NRU phototoxicity test was set up under OECD 432, how an in-chamber intensity of 1.69 mW/cm² for 50 minutes converts to the 5 J/cm² UVA dose, and why the in vitro result and the guinea pig result agree that neither substance is phototoxic. It also answers the questions that come up when specifying an irradiation system and controlling dose, and sets out the parameters of the LUYOR-3450 cell phototoxicity irradiator used in the study.

In 2025, Zhan Yibei's group at Hubei Polytechnic University, with Huanggang Meifeng Chemical, published a safety study on triazine ultraviolet filters in the Journal of Dermatologic Science and Cosmetic Technology (2025, 2: 100087) (Wei et al., doi:10.1016/j.jdsct.2025.100087): ethylhexyl triazone (EHT) and diethylhexyl butamido triazone (HEB) went through three genotoxicity tests and two phototoxicity tests, and the in vitro 3T3 NRU phototoxicity test followed OECD 432, with the 5 J/cm2 UVA dose delivered by a LUYOR-3450 cell phototoxicity irradiator. This article works through the irradiation parameters and design points along that test chain.

1. Why UV filters cannot skip phototoxicity testing

EHT and HEB are triazine ultraviolet filters. The conjugated triazine structure covers both UVA and UVB, the molecular weight is well above the 500 Da upper limit for skin penetration, and photostability and anti-inflammatory behavior are good, so both have entered sunscreen and skin care formulations. EU Cosmetics Regulation 1223/2009 approves EHT as a UV filter at a maximum of 5%.

But "absorbs ultraviolet" implies another risk: a compound that absorbs a photon can enter an excited state and, with oxygen present, damage cells - that is phototoxicity. For any light-absorbing cosmetic ingredient, regulation asks one question before market entry: at the same concentration, how far apart are the cell survival rates with and without light? The 3T3 NRU test in OECD 432 is the standard way to answer it.

2. How the 3T3 NRU test is set up

The test chain in the paper maps onto the OECD 432 framework step by step:

StepWhat the paper didNote
Cells and culture3T3 fibroblasts, 96-well plate, 5×104 cells/well24 h at 37 °C in a 5% CO2 incubator
Test treatmentSerial dilutions in Earle's balanced salt solution (EBSS), 1 h exposure8 concentration levels, 6 replicates per group
Positive controlChlorpromazine (CPZ)A known phototoxic substance, used to verify system sensitivity
Irradiation groups+UVA plate and -UVA dark plate run in parallelThe difference between the two is the contribution of light
Viability assayNeutral red 50 μg/mL for 3 h, extract and read absorbance at 540 nmSurvival gives IC50, which gives PIF and MPE

3. Irradiation parameters of the LUYOR-3450

The paper records the light source precisely: LUYOR-3450, three 365 nm 8W ultraviolet tubes, in-chamber UVA intensity range 1.3-2.2 mW/cm2; this test used a 5 J/cm2 dose, delivered as 50 minutes at the measured 1.69 mW/cm2.

ParameterValue in the paperOperating point
Wavelength365 nm (UVA)The UVA band required by OECD 432, no UVB
In-chamber intensity1.3-2.2 mW/cm2 (measured 1.69)Use the in-chamber radiometer reading, not the nominal tube rating
Dose and time5 J/cm2 = 1.69 mW/cm2 × 50 minDose (J/cm2) = intensity (mW/cm2) × time (s) / 1000
StoppingEnergy mode stops automatically at 5 J/cm2The internal sensor meters by energy, removing manual timing error
Sample placement96-well plate laid flat in the chamberChamber 26×32×15 cm; two 96-well plates fit side by side
TemperatureDual-fan cooling, chamber at or below 37 °CLong irradiation without heat stress skewing the result

One detail that is easily missed: the number of tubes does not set the dose, the measured in-chamber intensity does. The same nominal 8W tube, fitted three or four times and positioned differently, changes the in-chamber intensity - the practice in the paper is to calibrate with a radiometer before each test, then work back from "dose = intensity × time" to the exposure time. The energy mode of the LUYOR-3450 automates that step.

4. Results: in vitro and in vivo agree on no phototoxicity

GroupPIFMPEVerdict
Positive control CPZ9.7430.324Strong phototoxicity (system verified)
EHT10.044No phototoxicity
HEB10.098No phototoxicity

After irradiation the positive control IC50 fell to 150 μg/mL, against more than 1000 μg/mL in the dark, so the system separates phototoxicity from baseline toxicity sharply; for EHT and HEB the IC50 stayed above 1000 μg/mL with and without light, and both PIF and MPE stayed below the thresholds (PIF above 2 or MPE above 0.15 is judged phototoxic). The guinea pig skin phototoxicity test supports the same conclusion: erythema and edema scores in the EHT and HEB groups were 0 at 1, 24, 48 and 72 hours, while every animal in the 8-MOP positive control group showed moderate to severe erythema and edema on the irradiated side.

The three genotoxicity tests (Ames, chromosome aberration, micronucleus) also showed no significant abnormality at the high concentration of 6 mM. The whole evidence chain adds data to the existing regulatory conclusion of a 5% limit for EHT, and gives a citable safety basis for regions where approval is still pending.

5. Questions that come up often

Where does the 5 J/cm2 dose come from?
OECD 432 recommends a UVA dose of 5 J/cm2, an empirical value shared by laboratories. Running the test does not mean fixing the time: measure the in-chamber intensity (1.69 mW/cm2 here), then convert with dose = intensity × time to get 50 minutes. If the in-chamber intensity changes, the time has to be recalculated.
Why CPZ and 8-MOP as positive controls?
The 3T3 NRU test uses chlorpromazine, a classic reference with clear phototoxicity and a stable dose response in the literature; it shows that this set of cells, this lamp and this procedure can detect phototoxicity. The in vivo test uses 8-methoxypsoralen, which reliably produces erythema and edema after irradiation and anchors the animal test. A negative conclusion is not credible unless a positive control has run through the same system.
How are PIF and MPE read?
PIF is the ratio of the irradiated IC50 to the dark IC50: above 2 is a concern, above 5 is strong phototoxicity. MPE is the average photo-effect across the whole concentration curve, and above 0.15 is judged phototoxic. The two criteria work together: PIF is driven by the high-concentration end, MPE fills in the overall shape of the curve, and reading them together reduces misjudgment. For EHT and HEB here, PIF = 1 and MPE below 0.1, both well away from the thresholds.
Does a different number of tubes invalidate the test?
No, provided the dose is aligned. The paper used three 365 nm 8W tubes, while the 3450 ships with four as standard - the count changes the in-chamber intensity, and validity depends on whether the dose reaching the sample is still 5 J/cm2. The practice is to calibrate the in-chamber intensity at each run and stop on energy mode; a higher intensity shortens the time, a lower one lengthens it.
Source: Wei Y, Xiang M, Dong J, et al. Assessment of the potential genotoxicity and phototoxicity of triazine UV filters. Journal of Dermatologic Science and Cosmetic Technology, 2025, 2: 100087. DOI: 10.1016/j.jdsct.2025.100087
Download: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2950306X25000202
Related reading

LUYOR-3450 cell phototoxicity irradiator - designed for the 3T3 NRU test, with energy-mode auto-stop, temperature-controlled chamber and room for two 96-well plates; 18 questions on cell phototoxicity irradiation systems: OECD 432 dose, light source and filing - the overall guide to test design; Building a UVA cell model from cosmetic literature: LUYOR-3480 irradiation conditions - a comparable literature case, or contact us for 3450 selection and calibration support.

Related sections and models

This article belongs to the laboratory research techniques section.

Other sections on the same product line include UV irradiation chambers and photochemical reactors (quantitative irradiation of cells, microplates and materials) and life science instruments (the entry point for fluorescence imaging, UV crosslinking, UV transmission and cell irradiation).

Models mentioned in this article: LUYOR-3450, LUYOR-3480, LUYOR-3550. Ranges, accuracy and accessory lists for each model are given on the product page.

  • Official WeChat QR code

    Email: info@xinysun.com

  • Tel: 131-2093-6518

  • Address: 1525 Minqiang Road, Bldg 26, Songjiang, Shanghai

Official WeChat QR code Follow

Official WeChat QR code

Contact

131-2093-6518

Top